All the focus is on the winners in most tournaments. For a change, I thought I would offer a review of the four losing quarter-finalists following another dramatic night of magnificent entertainment at the East Wintergarden.
First up was German number one Simon Rosner, whose pink shirt matched by own subtle shirt and tie combination. Sartorial elements aside, I felt Rosner was capable of giving Barker a hard time.
Having witnessed him fight back from 8-4 down to win the third game against Nick Matthew in the North American Open a few short weeks ago, I was expecting to see more of the same.
However, Rosner never really got going. His length and width were never good enough to trouble Barker on a consistent basis and the biggest factor that contributed to his downfall was the alarming number of shots that clipped the top of the tin.
At times it was like listening to a panel beater on overtime.
The winning shots that produced such a dazzling cameo against Matthew failed to materialise. With his straight kills hitting the tin with such regularity, he needs to be aware of his body position leading in to the shot. At 6ft 3in tall, he needs to think about a few adjustments in his set-up and swing. That height gives him an advantage when hitting down on the ball, but last night he was clearly getting the angles slightly wrong.
Daryl Selby didn’t do a lot wrong against Nick Matthew. He has beaten him before, and, in front of a supportive home crowd, he was hoping to do a lot better last night.
The close scoreline in each game, plus the overall length of the match (65 minutes) illustrates the narrow gap between success and failure.
Matthew is a master at what he does, and Selby is not far behind him. In fact, he seems to be more relaxed on court these days, more mature in his behaviour, and enjoys revealing the kind of racket skills that result in sublimely satisfying crosscourt nicks.
Physically, Selby seems able to cope well with matches like these, soaking up the long rallies and brutal retrieving, and he is on the threshold of the kind of high-level advance that Matthew and Willstrop have both performed in their late 20s.
He is prepared to stay on court for as long as it takes to grind out a victory. The only problem last night was getting him off the court after the match hand finished as he continued his debate with the referee.
It is almost insultingly simple to offer up a solution that recommends hitting more winners and avoiding the tin, but sometimes the answers don’t need to bother an Einstein.
Egyptian Tarek Momen showed how a good a player he is and came close to following his victory over Nick Matthew in Qatar last year with another major scalp against James Willstrop in a pulsating match that enthralled a spellbound audience.
For Willstrop, there was a stark contrast between his battle to overcome Saurav Ghosal and the way he resisted an attacking onslaught from Momen.
The 24-year-old possesses a degree in mechanical engineering and he had obviously done his homework on Willstrop’s stress loads and the possible structural weaknesses of a large body mass required to make sudden movements.
Whereas Ghosal was running and chasing for the entire match, Momen matched fire with fire and delivered some astonishing kill shots from a variety of positions on court.
It was breathtaking squash, with a younger, smaller opponent who clearly had the confidence to take on Willstrop at the front of the court. As well as his speed around the court, Momen delivered flashes of genius with his racket, striking outrageous winners that were simply unplayable.
When Willstrop responded with prolonged spells of disciplined squash, he was able to contain his opponent’s genius and that’s when Momen made mistakes.
If he could go back to the science lab and undertake a performance analysis, we might see him return with an even fitter prototype model that did not drift out of the match for significant spells. Add a little patience to the mix and we might be seeing something really special.
Adrian Grant will be disappointed with his performance against Mohamed El Shorbagy, but any criticism must be tempered by the knowledge that he entered the tournament less than 100 per cent fit.
He was in some discomfort before and during his first round match against Chris Simpson, and although he returned to court with his right leg heavily strapped, he was able to move freely and hit some blinding winners on the glass court.
His pre-tournament advice from national coach Chris Robertson to hit more winners has obviously struck a chord, and I look forward to seeing how this appears in his new game strategy in the future. But he was given little opportunity to do so by a dominant, hard-hitting Mohamed El Shorbagy in the quarter-finals.
He was unable to shift the tall Egyptian from a dominant central position and the match was over in 30 minutes, the shortest of the night.
I am sure it would have been a different story had Grant been fitter.